"It's art. No one is wrong." Except me, because ... reasons?
My name is Krumbine. I'm a writer, filmmaker, and a general enthusiast for the art of storytelling. I call my YouTube channel Emergency Creative because, frankly, if I wasn't making videos, my head would be in a pretty bad way.
Recently, I posted a take on The Boys that ruffled some feathers. My argument was a good-faith attempt to look at the literal structure of the show as satire—not just the capes and the politics, but the actual nature of the episodes and seasons as a satirical take on the bloated, corporate nature of franchise media. I found that embracing this meta perspective actually helped me enjoy the show more.
Naturally, I got a comment that started with: "It’s art. No one is wrong. The only people that are, are people like you."
As a response to a video about meta-satire, c’mon … that's just hilarious.
Commentary vs. The Review Binary
This isn't a review channel, and it probably never will be. I love movies and TV, and I love talking about them, but I'm not trying to be the next big critic. Yes, I use "review" language in my descriptions because that's what the algorithm understands, but what I'm really offering is just pure commentary from a creative brain.
I'm not here to tell you why you should love or hate something. Like the commenter said: it’s art. No one is wrong.
I've argued that Jurassic World is a genius piece of meta-filmmaking that might be too smart for its own good.
I've admitted that Sharknado has terrible writing but remains top-tier "dumb fun".
I've even found magic in Fred Durst’s obscure thriller The Fanatic, where John Travolta gives an award-worthy performance of a character that probably shouldn't exist.
Review culture insists on a binary—good or bad, thumbs up or thumbs down. But that doesn't reflect how people actually enjoy things. Every person brings a lifetime of experience and nuance to a screen that changes how they see the production.
The Nature of the Tube
Sure, my thumbnail for the Boys video declared that the critics were "wrong," but that's just how YouTube works. I also spent plenty of time in that video saying I was probably an asshole and that my arguments were likely just a big ol’ steamy pile of cope.
If you want to hate on my takes, go for it—but it’ll always be a pale imitation of the hate I already have for myself!
My goal here is to provide a unique commentary so we can explore what inspires us to create and discover weird, cool stuff you might have missed. For instance, if you haven't seen Dicks: The Musical, you should. It's fucking incredible.
Closing the Loop
Maybe art isn't about being right or wrong—unless you're a soulless corporation making things for profit instead of passion. For the rest of us, maybe it’s just about discovering new ways to appreciate the world.
So, like what you like. Hate what you hate. And if I tell you that you're wrong, just remember that I'm an asshole and, according to the internet, I'm the only one who's actually wrong anyway.
###
